What is the difference
between an Advance Directive for Healthcare and a DNR?
 |
For those of you who have read this newsletter for
some time, you may recall that in November of 2008, I recounted the story
of my grandfather “Da.” As part of that story, I stated that
one day Da decided that he needed to do some things in the basement. He
turned on the light at the top of the stairs and started to walk down. At
some point along the way, he slipped and fell. The fall was a bad one. He
cut his head open and was bleeding profusely. Doing what she had to do, the
daytime caregiver called 911 and the EMTs came.
Even though the primary care physician had a Living Will and DNR order in
his file, when the EMTs arrived, they had to revive Da. I found out what
had happened later in the day and went to see him in the CCU at the
hospital. Da was not conscious, he was hooked up to many tubes and monitors
and he was just lying there in a fetal position. It was one of the saddest
sights that I have ever seen. He spent the next two weeks there, during
which time he regained consciousness, before being discharged to a skilled
nursing facility four blocks down the street.
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
Click here to request the Nuts and Bolts Guide to VA
Benefits |
|
To attend our monthly
Professionals’ Luncheon please call Louise Morris at 404-843-0121 or
email her at lmorris@HurleyECLaw.com |
If you answer yes to any
of these questions, Hurley Elder Care Law can help.
 |
 |
Has the elder been diagnosed with a mentally or
physically debilitating disorder such as Alzheimer’s,
Parkinson’s, ALS, stroke or a decline in functional capacity? |
 |
 |
|
Is the elder isolated due to the recent death of a
spouse, or have family that either lives too far away or is too busy to
provide adequate care? |
 |
 |
|
Is the elder soon to be discharged into a care facility
or currently receiving in-home care? |
 |
 |
|
Does the elder have a variety of healthcare providers
and need coordination and advocacy for quality care? |
 |
 |
|
Does the elder seem unusually concerned about costs of
medication and services, indicating he or she may be having financial
troubles? |
 |
 |
|
Does the elder have assets that fall between $50,000 and
$400,000 – enough to finance a short stay in a care facility but not
enough for an extended stay? |
 |
 |
|
Does the elder have a spouse whose financial needs must
be considered in light of the elder’s medical condition? |
|
Life Care Planning
Goals
- Meeting the elders’ immediate health
care and long-term care needs.
- Making sure the elder/family is making
good health care and long-term care decisions.
- Helping the elder/family sort through the
maze of their long-term care options including residential
options.
- Identifying and accessing public benefits
and resources to pay for care should the elder meet the qualifying
criteria.
- Help with asset management, including the
burden of home ownership and personal property.
- Providing the entire family the peace of
mind that comes from knowing their loved one is monitored by a team that
combines legal and financial expertise with specialized knowledge of the
elder’s physical, mental and emotional health.
- Ensuring the highest level of independence
the elder can achieve, while ensuring safety.
|
What is the difference
between an Advance Directive for Healthcare and a DNR?
 |
As
can be seen from this true life story, advance directives (in this case a
Living Will) and DNR orders play a significant role. Why, under the
circumstances described above did we have to endure a year of sadness and
no quality of life? The explanations can be seen and understood through the
questions and answers that follow.
What is a Georgia Advance Directive for Healthcare?
On July 1, 2007, the new Georgia Advance Directive for Healthcare replaced
the Georgia laws on the Living Will and the Durable Power of Attorney for
Healthcare. The new document is called the Georgia Advance
Directive for Healthcare.
The Georgia Advance Directive for Healthcare is a document that allows an
individual to appoint an agent to make medical treatment decisions on his
or her care if direct communication is not possible as
well as authorizes an individual’s doctor to withhold or
withdraw certain treatments or procedures. In addition, the document
contains specific HIPAA release language.
What type of procedures and treatments are you talking
about?
Treatments and procedures that may extend life for otherwise terminal
patients such as a ventilator, CPR, artificial nutrition (feeding tubes),
hydration (IV fluids) kidney dialysis, etc.
Why do I need to complete a Georgia Advance Directive for
Healthcare?
This document allows individuals to express their wishes about their own
end of life care even when they can’t communicate. It lets the family
and the doctor know what they want and what they do not want to happen to
them when they are near the end of their lives.
Is the Georgia Advance Directive for Healthcare the same as a
durable power of attorney for healthcare or my living will?
The Georgia Advance Directive for Healthcare combines these two documents
into a single legal document and makes it easier for individual's wishes to
be known. Durable powers of attorney and living wills made before July 1,
2007 are still valid. However, if possible the new document should be
executed.
What is a “Do Not Resuscitate” (DNR)
order?
A DNR order is a written order from a physician that informs medical
personnel that resuscitation should not be attempted if a person suffers
cardiac or respiratory arrest.
There are DNR orders in the hospital and then there are DNR orders written
for out in the community. Community can mean home, assisted living,
personal care home and skilled nursing home. Just because a person has a
DNR order in the hospital does not mean it will transfer out of the
hospital. If a person wants a DNR order once leaving the hospital another
one needs to be filled out for use in the community.
When does a physician write a DNR order?
A physician can write a DNR for a patient after a verbal conversation with
a competent adult patient or the person’s healthcare agent. Both the
agent and the doctor should try to abide by the person’s wishes,
which are listed in the Advance Directives. In some instances a physician
will write a DNR order when resuscitation will not alter the outcome of the
disease or if resuscitation will cause unnecessary suffering. Two
physician’s signatures are required for a DNR.
How will medical personnel know that a DNR order is in
place?
In a hospital or a skilled nursing home there will be a large notice on the
front of the chart. In the community identification necklaces and bracelets
are available and can be worn to make sure all medical personnel recognize
and adhere to patient’s wishes.
Does a DNR order stop medical personnel from treating a patient
completely?
No, a DNR only refers to resuscitation (CPR) efforts and does not interfere
with other treatments, for example: transfusions, dialysis, use of a
ventilator and antibiotic therapy. Treatment that keeps a person free of
pain and comfortable should always be given.
Can a DNR order be revoked?
Yes, DNR orders should be reviewed periodically by the doctor and revoked
if appropriate. A person can revoke his DNR at any time.
What is a “code”?
A code is a word that hospital and nursing homes use to mean resuscitation
efforts should be initiated.
What is a “no code”?
A “no code” is an informal name for a DNR.
In my grandfather’s case, he did not have a community DNR in place.
Without immediate knowledge of the existence of one that was held by his
doctors, the EMTs had to act. This was a difficult way to learn this
lesson. We hope that this bit of education may save your families from the
same problems.
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
 |
Miles Hurley
Miles
Hurley is the founding partner with Hurley Elder Care Law, which was
created to provide quality elder care law services at reasonable
prices. Continue reading »
|
|
| Speaking
Engagements |
|
Miles Hurley will speak at a breakfast
buffet at 7:15 a.m. on Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at the
Georgia Club located at 100 Galleria Parkway in Atlanta. He will speak at
the Executive Round Table of Business Owners on the importance of being
educated prior to a crisis. His topic, presented to members only, is
“You Don’t Know What You Don’t
Know.”

On
Thursday, February 19, 2009 at 8:00 a.m., Miles
Hurley will speak to members of the Institute of Continuing Legal
Education at the State Bar Headquarters located at 104 Marietta Street NW,
Suite 100, in Atlanta. The presentation will be on the subject of
Life Care Planning.
 At
6:00 p.m. on February 19, 2009, the North Atlanta Chapter
of the Georgia Society of Certified Public Accountants will have an address
by Miles Hurley on Life Care Planning. He will speak at
the Doubletree Hotel at 2055 S. Park Place near Marietta to chapter members
and their guests specifically on “Understanding How to Deal
with Aging.”
Visit
our site
for more events »
|
|
|
| |
 |
 |
Hurley Elder Care
Law
100
Galleria Parkway, SE
Suite 1345
Atlanta, GA 30339
Phone: 404.843.0121
Fax: 404.843.0129
|
 |
|